The digital divide and who gets to be healthy
October 7/2026
This story was originally published by Temerty Medicine.
By Erin Howe
What impact does technology — and our ability to engage with it — have on our health? It’s a question Jay Shaw, an associate professor of physical therapy at the University of Toronto and a scientist at Women’s College Hospital, is working to answer.
Shaw is the lead author of a new paper that examines how increasing digitization shapes our well-being, and what can be done to protect and promote health as technology rapidly evolves. The paper is the first in a three-part series in The Lancet exploring the digital determinants of health.
The second paper examines how digital media affect young people, while the third considers how policy and governance can support public health in the digital era.
Shaw, who is acting director of the Joint Centre for Bioethics in U of T’s Dalla Lana School of Public Health and holds the Canada Research Chair in Responsible Health Innovation, recently spoke with writer Erin Howe about the research and what it means for our increasingly digital lives.

(Photo by Tim Fraser/KITE Studio for University of Toronto, Department of Physical Therapy)
What are the digital determinants of health?
The digital determinants of health have to do with the digitization of everyday life and how these changes impact our health. The idea builds on earlier work on a variety of other insights from public health, like the ways that social, commercial and political systems impact the health and wellbeing of populations.
In this series, we explore big questions about how digital transformations are changing our social realities and how that affects human and planetary health. It’s widely understood that health-care systems have a modest influence on population health, whereas other aspects of our environments are more important. For example, our home environments, school systems and the jobs we have all determine the resources available to us to protect and promote our health. Digital transformation is changing those things, and so also changing how they impact our health — this is why we need to pay closer attention to the digitization of our everyday lives from a public health perspective.
The World Health Organization calls digitization a mega trend. What does this mean for public health?
In the paper, we refer to a 2025 survey of adults in the United States that suggested respondents, on average, spent more than six hours per day interacting with apps on their smartphones. We can imagine that the same goes for us here in Canada, where screens are part of the way we do almost everything, from how we shop and work to the kinds of recreation we participate in and the networks we maintain.
At the same time, a global policy group connected to the United Nations found that last year, 2.2 billion people across the world had no internet access. The African region was the least connected, which raises new questions. How do digital technologies shape health when access is uneven? That’s one of the concepts we try to emphasize in this series, that digital transformation shapes not just individual actions, but also the ways businesses run, how voting happens, who gets elected, and what kinds of information the global populace has access to. These are all major determinants of health.
We want to encourage access to technology so that everybody around the world benefits. But we need to make changes to ensure the risks can be prevented for everyone.
Do digital platforms help us be more engaged with our health data and good quality information? Are there drawbacks?
I tend to see the issue of health information and misinformation kind of like the front door to the digital determinants of health. If you get your health information from social media, you see a narrow and specific set of opinions about what’s true and what matters. Even if you get that information from an AI-powered chatbot, it follows rules around what it will and should present. These are concrete ways that our digital environment dictates what we know and believe about our health and about how to improve it.
For those of us working in health care, we tend to think about health-related applications of technology as those that are most relevant for our health, for example, like an app that allows someone to enter their heart rate and blood pressure to help them manage a chronic condition.
But we also need to think about broader technologies like large language models, which power tools like AI chat bots, that don’t necessarily have anything to do with health on the surface. Maybe they just help a person meal plan. But really, these platforms decide what kinds of information people are seeing, which can have enormous impacts on their health.
Digital determinants can work positively or negatively. Continuing with the example of a person using an app to plan meals, it could present healthy options and point toward fresh, home-cooked meals. But it could also point to low cost, ultra-processed options. Or there may be hidden advertisements or influencers who are paid to put forward positions that have nothing to do with whether they’re healthy or not, a form of guerrilla advertising that now has become so common in social media.
Is this uncharted territory, or are there parallels with other experiences with industry?
When we look at big technology corporations, there’s a lot of experience to draw on.
Social media companies are of course different from cigarette companies. But looking at the way big corporations have approached criticism, especially from scientists, there’s a pretty standard course of action they tend to take around science. Corporations will aim to discredit researchers whose work is critical of their products and will actively fund researchers to study questions that align with their products and business models. But industry funding of research produces conflicts of interest in science, which means that the results of research are biased in favour of messages that align with the companies’ interests.
In the series, we suggest that universities and academic health sciences centres have a responsibility to prevent the conflicts of interest that come with industry funding.
For the team of authors on this series to be able to point to this broader set of technologies and how they impact our health, we need to be protected by the institutions we work for and against conflicts of interest from industry-sponsored science.
We need transparency around these technologies and how they impact our health.
What do you hope readers will take away from this series?
I want to encourage people to think about how technology shapes their health.
Digitization produces new health-promoting opportunities, like having good relationships despite distance, or enabling access to new educational opportunities. But it’s also important to be aware of how technology can present risks to health, like the comparison that comes through social media and the resulting challenges to mental health, especially for youth.
There are also broader risks to health as business models and politics change. And now some people who manipulate what we see on social media can dictate the course of a country. These kinds of things happen. Researchers at Stanford who have shown that exposure to a particular kind of messaging on social media has led to reduced trust in the public health institutions in the United States. When we have, at a population level, reduced trust in the institutions that are designed to protect the public’s health, we’re in real trouble.
But most importantly, we want to emphasize that this is not a problem of individual willpower — we need better policy and governance to make sure these issues are dealt with before they arrive on our smartphone screens.
How has digitalization contributed to the spread of misinformation?
This is a complex problem with many layers! There’s a very small group of bad actors who spread misinformation for personal gain. And then there’s a much larger group of people who share and spread information because they genuinely think what they’re sharing is true. They don’t have mal-intent, and this really complicates it. The fact that it can happen so quickly in a digital world, and so many more people are exposed to false claims about health, scales the misinformation problem way up. This is a central issue for the digital determinants of health.
How did you come to become interested the effects of digitization on health?
I’ve studied technology in health care and public health for years, looking at questions around how people interact with new apps to self-manage their diabetes, for example.
Early on, some colleagues and I saw there were members of structurally marginalized communities who wouldn’t engage with those tools at all. We dug more deeply to find out why and discovered a whole reality around how these apps are designed, who the app designers have in mind, and how policy addresses that.
Pushing the topic further, I then saw how the whole world of technology outside of health care also affects our health. I started to peel back layers around that and pursued some research funding to bring together seven community researchers from low-income communities in Toronto to dig deeper.
We did a project where we asked, “What are your priorities around how technology impacts your health?” Through that process, we illuminated the ways technology shapes what people can and can’t do in relation to their health.
That work helped me develop a stronger understanding of perspectives from community members and what really matters to them. Then I began to think bigger and see the importance of building systems that don’t place so much burden on the health of individuals.